Early today Lebron James chose to play for the Miami Heat and join Chris Bosh and Dwayne Wade to hopefully win some NBA titles. One of the toughest things as a professional athlete of Lebron James' stature is that it is impossible to please everyone and every professional move you make is bound to be criticized one way or another. This decision is far from an exception. The fans in Cleveland are distraught while the city of Miami will be celebrating all night. Some Cleveland fans have taken the news better than others. One particularly poor sport about Lebron's decision is Cleveland Cavaliers owner Dan Gilbert who has said that Lebron will be cursed and that the Cavaliers without Lebron will win a championship before Lebron does with Miami.
We've all heard the hype...we now know the decision...some are crushed and some elated.
As a basketball fan neutral (no emotional feelings) to this situation as a Phoenix Suns fan which was not even an issue for James, I am going to try to do my best and be as objective as possible to rate Lebron's move. I give it a B+.
First, I think Lebron should have stayed in Cleveland if he was going to build this event up like he did. By the time the event started 47 states out of 50 already knew where Lebron would land, and the states of Ohio, New York and Illinois were simply being overly optimistic. Lebron James building the event the way he did only to tell the nation that he would be leaving his home town was a bit tough to deal with for Cleveland fans all of whom were forced to watch the special and very minute of his announcement in anticipation to hear him "officially" announce. I understand Cleveland's frustration with the way he handled himself which is why I cannot give Lebron an A for the decision he made. Nonetheless, Lebron reasonably stated that he could not make an emotional decision but rather a decision that was best for him. I think Lebron should have worked in Cleveland to bring the pieces together and give the city of Cleveland its first sports championship in almost four decades. However, Lebron wanted to go somewhere that he would have the most fun and have the best shot of winning a championship.
I understand why James left Cleveland. After all, James, Wade, and Bosh are all buddies who all came out in the first five picks of the 2003 NBA draft. Is it a coincidence that their contracts all expired in during the exact same year? Perhaps not. This was a dream team that seemed unlikely but given the opportunity was something the players simply could not pass up. Lebron certainly will enjoy his time working with two stars in Dwayne Wade and Chris Bosh; however, from a winning championships standpoint, he may have had a better chance to win in Chicago where the pieces were already catered to Lebron with young talent such as Derek Rose and Joakim Noah along with newly acquired veteran Carlos Boozer. Unlike in Miami, the Chicago Bulls would not have to get a fresh new roster to sign Lebron whereas Miami will have to acquire a lot of newcomers.
Lebron grew up his entire life in Chicago and was the face of Ohio with a huge following. It is tough to see him leave after getting so close to a championship and diminishing the little glimmer of hope Cleveland had for a city that really needed it. Even as a non-Cleveland fan I will find it tough to root for Lebron James and the Miami Heat. However, this Heat team will certainly be fun to watch as any sports fan has to be curious how this new squad will pan out. While Lebron certainly did not handle the situation ideally, you certainly cannot put that much blame on Lebron. After all, I genuinely believe his decision was not one to ditch Cleveland as much as it was one to join Dwayne Wade and Chris Bosh.